But you ask a young person to roll up his sleeves
and give a hand to
cleaning up the streets of Addis Ababa, or do some
manual work,
rather than embarrass the country by begging
visitors and tourists,
and he will feel insulted about being told to do
manual work.
You wonder: if he is willing to take enormous risks
like facing
artillery fire and land mines on the battlefield for
his country, why
is he unwilling to work to keep Addis Ababa's
streets clean?
In May 2000, Ethiopia went to war with Eritrea. Many
months later,
most Ethiopians and Eritreans in Kampala would tell
me: "That war was
between Meles and Issias. The Ethiopian and Eritrean
people have no
problem with each other."
I asked that if this was so, why were so many young
people, boys and
girls, struggling to go to the war front? "Because
they love their
country!", would come the reply.
See a contrasting situation. In June 2000, just a
few weeks into the
Ethiopian-Eritrean war, Uganda and Rwanda ---- which
like Ethiopia
and Eritrea are neighbours and former close allies
in the guerilla
struggles ---- fought in the Congolese city of
Kisangani.
Most Ugandans calmly went about their everyday
business,
saying, "That is a quarrel between President
Museveni and Major
General Paul Kagame [leader of Rwanda]. When they
are tired of
fighting, they will come back and talk."
No single Ugandan civilian went to the battlefront
or volunteered to
fight in a conflict that they felt was between two
leaders.
That's
where we are different.
When the Israeli air force attacked Entebbe airport
in that famous
commando raid in July 1976, very few Ugandans came
forward to
volunteer to fight for President Idi Amin. We
reasoned that it was he
who had provoked the Israelis. And anyway, he was a
dictator and
deserved that beating.
When Tanzania invaded Uganda after Amin first
attacked Tanzania in
October 1978, again no Ugandans except for the army
and air force
bothered to come out to "fight for my country."
We supported the Tanzanians all the way, until they
removed Amin from
power.
Even though another country (Israel, Tanzania)
invaded Uganda,
Ugandans were able to separate their love for their
country, from the
fact that it was Uganda's leader who had provoked
that country
and
therefore deserved what he got.
Since most Ethiopians find it hard to separate their
emotions from
their country, it is easy to lead Ethiopians into
expensive and
pointless wars and conflicts , when the fight might
really be a
personal quarrel between Ethiopia's Colonel Mengistu
and
Somalia's
President, General Mohammed Siad Barre.
Things that Uganda would laugh off and let pass
without any problem,
will get Ethiopians so worked up and angry. You can
meet a Ugandan
and tell them you think Uganda is the greatest
country in the world,
and they will reply, "Well, thanks."
Then later you can tell the same Ugandan that you
now think that
Uganda is the most foolish and backward country in
the world. To
this, the Ugandan will calmly reply, "What makes you
say that?" None
of the two statements will cause the Ugandan to get
over excited or
angry.
While I was in Addis Ababa, a Rwandese living in
Europe who had
visited Uganda, wrote an article dismissing Uganda
as one of the
worst countries he has ever seen. He criticized the
restaurants,
nightclubs, taxis, roads, and the whole country.
The article was one of the most popular that week, I
am told. People
laughed about it and it was the topic in bars and
offices. No matter
how much you insult Uganda, you can't get any one
annoyed over
that.
To begin with, Ugandans spend much of their time
laughing at their
country's silly mistakes and confused leaders.
This balanced thinking, this control of one's
emotions cuts
across
almost every area of Ugandan society, from the
leaders to the poorest
of the poor.
To me, the admirable love for Ethiopia that almost
all Ethiopians
feel is also the most frightening thing about
Ethiopia, and something
I feel is the country's greatest danger.
It is this trait which, if not checked, will make
Ethiopia take 10
steps forward in economic and political progress,
only to suddenly
plunge back 40 steps into war, ethnic tensions, and
factional
fighting within whichever government is in power.
Here is the paradox: how can people like Ethiopians,
who love their
country so much, be the same people who do the
country its greatest
harm, yet people like Kenyans and Tanzanians, who
seem indifferent to
their country, have actually helped their countries
remain so stable
for so long? Could it be that too much patriotism
can be more harmful
to a country than not caring about one's country?
Usually when an Ethiopian is not pleased by what you
have said about
Ethiopia, he gets so angry, and can even stop
talking to you over
that.
It happened to me in Addis Ababa. I also got a taste
of it when some
Ethiopians and Eritreans in America and Europe
visited my Africa
Almanac web site.
They disagreed with some of the content there
regarding Ethiopia and
Eritrea. This is a website which I launched in
December 2000, long
before I knew either of these two countries well. Of
course I was
bound to make a few errors, because as a human
being, I did not know
enough to get their complex histories correct.
But you should see the e-mail from these Ethiopians
and
Eritreans! "You are the most stupid man in the
world!", read one.
I wrote back to them calmly asking that, even if
they disagreed with
what I had written, they did not have to lose their
self-control and
insult me. Should they not rather have informed me
of the facts,
instead of blowing up in anger?
Unable to reason this out, they wrote back to me
with even more
abusive words.
I told them that this is the central crisis in their
countries,
Ethiopia and Eritrea. Before Ethiopians and
Eritreans visited my web
site, the letters from other Africans were
gentlemanly, respectful,
rational, and even when they disagreed with what the
web site had
said; they did so in a reasonable manner.
But as soon as the Ethiopians came in and began
giving their
comments, suddenly the tone became aggressive and
unreasonable.
I reminded them that, even after spending so many
years in America,
these Ethiopians writing from the United States had
still not
developed the tolerance of other people's views that
is required
for
democracy to flourish.
Many of the Ethiopians are in America as political
exiles. They blame
Prime Minister Meles Zenawi for all the problems in
Ethiopia, saying
he is crushing and suppressing all views opposed to
his.
But I told them that, just from their abusive and
angry e-mail to my
web site, if they had even 10 percent of the power
that Prime
Minister Meles has, they would probably have ordered
for my arrest or
thrown a grenade at my house.
You are late for an appointment or for some reason
you can't make
it,
and your Ethiopian friend gets so, so angry for a
whole day. That is
a dangerous national streak and character!
A girl who was staying at the National Hotel asked
me to lend her a
camera for a trip with some Ethiopian and American
friends to Bahr
Dar. I told her that I was using mine, but I would
ask around for one
from my friends. Two days later, after I failed to
find one, she said
impatiently, "I am going to stop talking to you
because you
didn't
get me a camera!"
One girl in Kampala invited me to visit her at a
time I was so busy.
I kept trying to make it to her place but couldn't
somehow find
the
time. One day when I think her patience was
exhausted, she rang me at
home and blasted me with the words, "What's wrong
with you!" I
tried
to explain why I had failed to turn up, but by then,
her temper was
already in flames.
Yet when I met her that evening, she was calm, and
her usual nice
self. There are too many examples of this, but I
begin to feel
frightened by people who's emotions can so suddenly
switch on and
off, from cool, sweet, warm, to angry and
uncompromising!
(Some of the people I am writing about will read
this article and
probably laugh, knowing what I am talking about!)
Ethiopians are nice people, really sincere and in my
opinion,
wonderful people. But there is a demon that flies
from nowhere once
in a while and plunges them into a state of mind
that can only lead
to conflict and self-destruction.
I have been telling my Ethiopian friends both in
Kampala and Addis
that they should not think that what happened to
Somalia was
different and it can't happen to them. Most think
Ethiopia
can't go
to that extreme. But, you never know. That fiery,
volatile
temperament I see in Ethiopians gets me worried sometimes.
A teenage Ethiopian girl in Kampala put it well to
me one day in late
May: "Ethiopians are like that. Once they like you,
they will like
you to death. But once they turn against you, it is
finished."
Frightening words!
It is as if stubbornness and intransigence is
written into most
peoples' minds --- people who find it difficult to
think with
flexibility, people who struggle to detach
themselves from their
emotions and think clearly and objectively about
Ethiopia.
But then, where did this trait come from? A trait
that has kept
Ethiopia more or less in a state of war or near war
for more than 200
consecutive years or even more? Ethiopians have
fought the people who
tried to enslave or colonize them. But so too have
they, with equal
ferocity, fought amongst themselves, and still do to
this day.
There is this liberation front, that liberation
front, this fighting
group, that fighting group.
Where does this tendency come from, which it seems
will keep the Horn
of Africa, from Somalia, to Eritrea, to Ethiopia, to
Sudan, a virtual
war zone for the next 30 or more years?
How can people whom I find so sweet, beautiful,
loving, modest,
sincere, and loyal, at the same time have this other
side to them
that is like a volcano --- dormant most of the time,
but once it
erupts, it throws destructive fire for several
kilometres in its path?
Did the Ethiopian Orthodox Church shape national
character?
When I returned to Uganda the first time in
February, I was having
lunch with an Ethiopian in Kampala. I asked him a
question, which
popped up in my mind from out of the blue.
I asked him: Why is it that, wherever in the world
you find countries
where the Orthodox Church is the dominant Christian
denomination,
there is either full-scale war (Yugoslavia, Serbia),
or recent war
and tensions (Ethiopia, Eritrea), or serious civil
war and trouble
with provinces that want to break away (Russia), or
have had to have
United Nations intervention to prevent war between
them (Greece,
Cyprus), or some stubbornness that could make war
possible at any
time (Ukraine)?
Then why is it that, wherever in the world Islam is
the dominant
religion, there are either suicide bombers
(Lebanon), militant
militiamen (Algeria, Egypt, Somalia, Iran, Bosnia,
Albania, Sudan) or
they are generally a trouble spot?
Then worst of all, in the places in the world where
Islam and
Orthodox Christianity sit side by side in equal
percentages among the
population, conflict, war, factional fighting, or
extreme political
tensions are alive and dominant (Ethiopia, Eritrea,
Bosnia-
Herzegovina, Russia, Chechnya).
Why, in other words, does the Orthodox branch of
Christianity
influence its followers to become so
ultra-nationalistic, and hence
so militant that almost every disagreement has to be
settled on the
battlefront?
Where does this militancy in the Horn of Africa come
from?
Since I am a Protestant Christian, I will not
comment on Islam, where
I am no expert. But I will hope that my brothers and
sisters of the
Ethiopian and other Orthodox Churches in Africa and
Europe search
their souls over this matter.
I am not saying the Orthodox faith promotes war and
war-like
tendencies. We too have crazy, uncompromising
Protestants and Roman
Catholics shooting away at each other in Northern
Ireland. In
Indonesia and the Philippines, street battles have
become the main
way of life between Christians and Muslims.
But the dominant pattern of war and internal civil conflict in
Orthodox-dominated countries in Africa and Europe is
inescapable. I
hope I don't appear to be blaming the Ethiopian
Orthodox Church
for
the country's political tensions and many past wars.
I am only
trying
to study a pattern and see if it offers
explanations.
From the little I know, I can say this: the Orthodox
churches have,
at the centre of their belief system, the idea that
they are national
churches.
They are not simply part of the general body of
Christ, but they
often take on a national character. Thus, you have
the Ethiopian
Orthodox Church, the Greek Orthdox Church, the
Ukrainian Orthodox
Church, and the Russian Orthodox Church.) They bear
the names of the
nations in which their roots are planted.
They also seem to instill in their followers an
extreme loyalty, a
spiritual and emotional connection to their country.
To an Orthodox,
his country is his father-mother, his very being and
reason for
existence.
People are willing to sacrifice their lives for Ethiopia. Olympic
champions give their medals to a church, out of
gratitude for their> victories.
That is the patriotism that is so striking in
Ethiopia. People
revolve their lives around service to their country.
It is the same
in Russia, Greece, Eritrea, Yugoslavia, Ukraine,
Macedonia, and
Cyprus.
Even military dictators like Joseph Stalin of the
Soviet Union and
Colonel Mengistu Haile Mariam, although they were
Communist and had
no time for religion, were raised in this atmosphere
of extreme
patriotism and so reflected the influence of the
Orthodox Church.
All this patriotism is fine and admirable. As I
mentioned in my very
first article in February, if only Ugandans had the
national spirit
that the Ethiopians have, we would be so far ahead
of where we are
today in economic development.
But....it gets to a point where this patriotism can
become self-
destructive, if it is not controlled.
And this is the danger I see facing Ethiopia. If you
can't stop
and
shout, "Hey, let sanity prevail!", before you know
it, your country
could be in flames, such as what we are witnessing
in Yugoslavia and
what we saw in 1974 between Greece and Cyprus, when
the United
Nations had to intervene.
We need to understand our history. Ethiopians might
be putting all
their blame on governments as the cause of their
national problems,
yet the same problems existed even before Prime
Minister Meles Zenawi
was born.
He himself blamed Ethiopia's problems on the
dictator Colonel
Mengistu and so went to the bush to start a student
guerrilla
uprising --- only to come to power and I am sure by
now, 10 years on,
has realized that the problems are so deep, anyone
in power in Addis
Ababa will be tempted to react exactly as Mengistu
did.
Pope John Paul II visited Greece and Ukraine within
the past two
years. For several days before he arrived in Athens,
priests and nuns
of the Greek Orthodox Church staged demonstrations
in the streets,
denouncing him and threatening him if he set foot on
Greek soil. The
same thing happened in Kiev, the capital of Ukraine.
What these hard-line priests and nuns forgot was
that as head of the
Vatican, the Pope is a Head of State, not just the
head of the Roman
Catholic Church. At least in his capacity as a Head
of State, he
deserves the minimum of a formal diplomatic welcome.
When he visited Syria, a predominantly Muslim
country, he was warmly
received, even though the differences between Islam
and Christianity
are greater than the divisions between the Roman
Catholic Church and
the Orthodox Church.
When your very being, your whole personality is tied
with your
country and state, when the question of your
nationality and
ethnicity is the main reason for your existence, it
can land you into
trouble, because by their nature, governments and
states are not
always sincere, not always rational, and peaceful.
How can a whole nation tie its deepest emotions with
those of the
state, ruled as it is by politicians, who are often
the most
unreliable people of all?
How can you want to die for your country, when the
people who lead it
are mere mortal humans, with their own political
agendas, who use
your sentiments to their advantage, even as you
suffer? How can
people not see these things?
This extreme loyalty to one's country lives in
nearly every
Ethiopian, particularly those of the Orthodox faith.
It might perhaps
be one of the explanations for the tendency to be
volatile that is so
easy to observe in the Ethiopian character.
The illusions of national greatness
In May, the South African pay TV network M-Net held
the finals of the
M-Net Face of Africa modeling competition. The title
for 2001 was won
in style ---- and really deservingly so --- by a
dashing and charming
girl from Senegal.
Two days later, when I met an Ethiopian girl in
Kampala, she was
angry. She wanted to write a letter to M-Net in
Johannesburg and ask
why they did not have an Ethiopian girl among the 24
African
finalists.
First, I had to cool her down.
As a typical Ethiopian, she first heated up to 300
degrees centigrade
before she had time to think. I had to try and bring
her temperature
down to the normal human 37 degrees, before we could
talk.
As usual, she could not help the typical suspicious
Ethiopian way of
viewing the world. They are against us, they are out
to get us, there
is a hidden agenda by the Whites against Ethiopia.
Classic Ethiopian
mentality.
First, my friend couldn't think that there was also
no Ugandan girl
in the Face of Africa finals and yet I wasn't
complaining.
Secondly, if these Whites in South Africa are so
discriminating
against some Black Africans, how come all the
winners of this 200,000-
dollar prize have been Black Africans, and not White
South Africans?
Then I asked this girl: surely, you know the shyness
and reserve of
your fellow Ethiopian girls. Can you realistically
expect shy,
modest, soft-spoken, self-conscious Ethiopians to
win international
competitions as fierce as these, where the stakes
are so high?
Finally, only after I reasoned calmly with my friend
and with her
temper back to normal, did she admit that, yes, the
beautiful and
electrifying girl from Senegal had won the title
outright. No more
argument.
I did not watch the finals that Saturday night, but
when I eventually
watched parts of it on CNN television the next week,
not only did I
confirm that the Senegalese girl was indeed the
deserving winner, but
that this charming girl is going to become one of
the most successful
models on the world stage very soon.
That Senegalese is even better than some of these
international
models like Naomi Campbell, Tyra Banks, or Cyndi
Crawford!
I wondered: did my Ethiopian friend first have to
get into a heated
mood, threaten M-Net, before I could calmly made her
see that, if she
had thought in a balanced way before getting all
heated up, she would
have come to the same conclusion as me, that the
girl from Senegal
deserved to win?
Just multiply this Ethiopian girl's explode-fi
rst-then-think-later
typical reaction by 64 million people, and you begin
to understand
the difficulty involved in governing Ethiopia, even
if you were St.
Gabriel himself!
However, this Ethiopian attitude did not just come
from nowhere.
Apparently, Ethiopians are raised under what seems
to outsiders to be
brainwashing. They are raised as children to believe
that their
country is the greatest on earth.
Most Ethiopians genuinely believe that their land is
the most
fertile, their country is the greenest, their food
the ideal and
best, their women the most beautiful in the world,
their history is
richer than that of any other nation, their climate
gives them "13
months of sunshine", their country is mentioned
countless times in
the Bible, their music is the best on earth, their
traditional
clothing the finest, and of course, they are the
only Black people on
earth who successfully beat off colonial rule.
About the general greatness of Ethiopia, there can
be no doubt. I
have written and agreed many times that this is
true. Ethiopia, to
me, ranks or should rank among Africa's top five
countries by
virtue
of its cultural heritage. There is no question about
that.
But Ethiopians might also need to take a close,
objective look at the
rest of the world, and their eyes will be opened to
the fact that as
great as Ethiopia certainly is, there are many other
countries that
as just as great or even greater.
As I asked in my recent long article in June,
Ethiopia and the fate
of Africa , if the country is all that great, it
should have been
somewhere in the top 10 of the economic table of the
world. But even
in comparison with the rest of Africa, Ethiopia is
among the bottom
10.
A painful fact, I know, but better to be bravely
faced than pretend
the evidence is not there.
If the girls are all that beautiful and elegant, why
have we never
heard of a Miss World from Ethiopia?
If the country has produced so many well-educated,
talented people,
so many scientists, who now live in the "Diaspora"
in America,
Britain, or Sweden, how come we never hear of an
Ethiopian Grammy
music award winner, an Ethiopian Pulitzer Prize
winner, a Nobel Prize
winner, an Academy film award winner?
You can't just say the reason is because the whole
world hates
Ethiopia.
If the whole world hates Ethiopia, how come that
same world,
especially the White western world, has given so
many Olympic and
world championship gold, silver, and bronze medals
to Bekila Abebe,
Miruts Yifter, Derartu Tulu, Haile Gebreselassie?
How come this
same "biased" world has not stood in the way of
these Ethiopian world-
class athletes becoming famous and quite rich?
In other words, it is time for Ethiopia to start
seeing things in a
broad, balanced way, for its own good. When you are
truly great, even
the biased, racist White world still takes note of
you.
If Ethiopia is lagging behind even most of Africa,
the answer could
simply be that we might not be as great as we
imagine we are.
When I came to Addis Ababa last month, I made a
point of carrying
photographs of parts of Uganda and Tanzania's island
of Zanzibar,
as
well as Zimbabwe.
Many Ethiopians I showed the photos were very
surprised by what they
saw --- the dazzling beauty of Zanzibar, with its
coconut trees,
white sand, and blue ocean; the breathtaking beauty
of the Victoria
Falls of Zimbabwe at sunset, and Uganda where the
country is green
all year round.
It opened a few eyes to the illusions of greatness
that most
Ethiopians are raised to believe. Yes, Ethiopia is
beautiful. But so
are dozens of other countries like Uganda, the
Bahamas, Kenya, South
Africa, Tanzania, and the Seychelles.
God's handiwork is spread all over the earth, not
just over
Ethiopia.
I also quietly told some of my Ethiopian friends to
revise their
illusion that only Ethiopian girls are beautiful on
the face of this
earth. This is because one day they will travel abroad and, surprise,
surprise, they will see other girls who will leave
them breathless.
This idea of somehow being the most beautiful breed
of people on
earth seems to me to be a central theme in most
Ethiopians'
minds, so
I will comment at length on it.
But ask those people who have been to Nairobi,
Kenya. Or western
Uganda. Or Rwanda, Burundi, Tanzania. Go to
Zanzibar. Somalia. Mali.
The West Indies. The Bahamas and Barbados. Some of
the Black
Americans and Black British.
Have you seen some of these girls from India who
have won the Miss
World beauty pageant? Can anyone argue that they did
not deserve to
win?
Even these Whites. The Black beauty we have in
Africa is not the only
one on earth. Take a look at the 20 year-old
American Pop singer,
Britney Spears. She is White. But what a beauty she
is!
Remember the late Princess Diana? Who can argue
about that? Or
Marilyn Monroe? Cyndi Crawford? The American Country
music singer
Faith Hill? There is this American actress Cybil
Shepherd. I think
she really is a truly beautiful woman.
Have you seen some of these White women who appear
on the adverts of
the brandy Remy? Or in the fashion magazines Vogue
and Cosmopolitan.
I think that too is pure beauty.
I even see some of the many White girls, the
tourists who walk
aimlessly through the streets of Kampala, wearing
dirty slippers and
dirty T-shirts, with their funny blue eyes and
blonde hair. Some of
them should be models.
True, Ethiopian girls are beautiful. Very beautiful.
But so are those
from many other African and Caribbean countries.
Because Ethiopia has
a large population, the abundance of feminine beauty
is more
noticeable.
That is why I think a visit to another large city
like Nairobi would
help people in Addis Ababa see things from a broader
perspective.
What you see might surprise you.
Blacks, Whites, Asians, as far as I am concerned,
all have among them
very beautiful people. Let us not think that we
Africans are the only
people God chose to make beautiful!
Then there is that other beauty that they call inner
beauty, which at
the end of the day is the only beauty that time does
not erase.
One of the problems with thinking of yourselves as
the most beautiful
on earth is that it breeds vanity and surely those
who believe in God
have some idea about what God thinks of pride.
But more importantly, if you have this adamant idea
that your girls
are the world's most beautiful, then it is obvious
what it leads
to ---- SEGREGATION.
Not everyone in any society can be beautiful. If
being beautiful is
something Ethiopians hold as dear a part of their
identity as having
not been colonized, then obviously they will become
ashamed or uneasy
about those people in Ethiopia who are not
beautiful.
You then have to start living a lie or keeping up
superficial
appearances, when your identity is based on vanity,
rather than
better reasons to be proud, for example being proud
that your country
is a just society which treats all of its people
equally. That is a
more sensible thing to be proud of than perishable
human beauty.
While I was in Addis Ababa, I saw several Ethiopians
who in terms of
appearance look identical to the very dark-skinned,
Black people of
southern Sudan. They speak Amharic and are
Ethiopians in every way.
A British girl whom I sat next to on the flight to
Addis Ababa in
February, told me when she came back to Kampala that
the general
population in Ethiopia tends to look down upon these
dark-skinned
Ethiopians. I refused to believe her.
But this second time in Addis Ababa, I noticed that
these people
seemed to be strangers in their own land. They walk
through the
streets of Addis Ababa as a group, with people
staring at them.
I did not see a single one of these Ethiopians doing
business, owning
a shop, or in a position that seemed one of
advantage and prosperity.
I wondered what they do for a living.
What I saw quietly troubled me. But it did not
surprise me. When you
build a national identity that revolves around the
myth of beauty and
cultural superiority, rather than on justice and
fairness, you
inevitably have these uncomfortable situations of
unstated
discrimination.
When I returned to Kampala, I had photographs of the
many places I
visited in Ethiopia --- the nice ECA office
buildings, the Sheraton
Addis, inside Fasika restaurant with its attractive
artwork, Debre
Zeit, Nazareth, and the countryside.
When an Ethiopian friend of mine saw some
photographs of the simple,
humble people riding on horse-drawn carts along
muddy roads in Debre
Zeit, she angrily exclaimed: "Why did you have to
take photos of
these?"
I asked: "But I thought you Ethiopians love your
country. Is this not
Ethiopia too? Are those poor people in Debre Zeit
not Ethiopians
also?"
To her, Ethiopia is the attractive images you see in
Selemta , the in-
flight magazine of Ethiopian Airlines --- beautiful
women, the Hilton
and Addis Sheraton hotels, the new ECA conference
centre, the great
rock-hewn churches in Lalibela, the castles in
Gondar, the Blue Nile
waterfalls in Bahir Dar, the great Olympic
champions.
The severe poverty in the small towns like Debre
Zeit, which touched
my heart so deeply, is something that many urban
Ethiopians would
rather not talk about. They would rather that the
visitor walked
through the well-lit corridors of the Sheraton Addis
Ababa, and
return home with the Sheraton as the total image of
Ethiopia.
But then, what happens to some of us ugly people?
Should we be sent
to prison because we don't meet beauty standards?
(Come to think of it, maybe I should also launch an
Ethiopian
guerrilla group and call it the Ugly People's
Liberation Front
(UPLF), to fight for the rights of the ugly people!)
I think Ethiopians should start traveling and seeing
other countries.
Expand your view! See the broader world. Make
friends! The days of a
closed world called Ethiopia should come to an end.
All across
Africa, these are your brothers and sisters.
An Ethiopian told me of how he brought his relative
by road from
Ethiopia through Kenya to Uganda. When they entered
Uganda, the young
man asked, "Where are we?" His uncle replied that
they were now in
Uganda. The boy could not believe his eyes!
"All along," the young man said, "we are brought
up
to believe that
Ethiopia was the greenest country around. What is
this I am seeing!"
What he was seeing was Uganda. Green from January to
December. But
you rarely hear Ugandans talk about it!
Some Ethiopians have told me the same thing. They
step outside
Ethiopia, carrying all the legends and myths they
have been fed on
since childhood.
Then they discover that there are other countries
with advanced
cities, beautiful women, green and fertile land,
sophisticated
people, and rich histories, and suddenly they are in
a crisis.
Many get into a denial mode, stubbornly arguing that
Ethiopia is
still number one, despite the evidence before their
eyes.
When I appeared as a guest on Tefera Ghedamu's Meet
ETV show, I
complained about the many Ethiopians who are
struggling to leave the
country. I feel that Ethiopians --- who were never
colonized ---
should set a better than the rest of us Africans, by
not flooding
America and Europe, as if we don't have a home.
We end up making the Whites believe even more that
they are superior
to us. Our floods of people fighting to enter their
countries have
made the Whites feel more confident that without
them and their help,
the Black people are nowhere.
But on the other hand, I am sometimes tempted to
welcome this new
craze about going abroad, which I will address in a
later part of
this article.
Let these young Ethiopians, who have been raised on
a narrow, inward-
looking menu of illusions, go abroad, open up to the
world, see wider
places, see the variety of countries and as a
result, develop a more
international outlook than the feeling that the
world starts and ends
with Ethiopia.
Discomfort with other nations
A Ugandan friend of mine in Kampala called Michael
attended a
workshop in July which several people from several
African countries
attended. Commenting about the Ethiopians he met at
the workshop, he
said: "They [Ethiopians] are painful people to be
around!"
He said they are tense, not free with other people,
generally only
free with fellow Ethiopians. I understood what he
meant.
An Ethiopian journalist not long ago went to
Washington and when she
returned to Addis Ababa, she wrote an article on her
experience of
the Ethiopian community in the United States. Her
conclusions were
almost identical to those of other people who know
Ethiopians
elsewhere in the world.
They keep to themselves, find it difficult to mingle
with other
people, and even if countries where freedom abounds,
the Ethiopians
still do not become outspoken or take part in the
life of these
countries.
White South Africa
Since apartheid ended in South Africa, the huge
White South African
businesses have began spreading all over Africa. I
have been
observing the White South Africans, who are already
starting to
dominate business in Uganda. I still can't believe
those people.
These are people who were raised from childhood in a
country where
racial separation and the tendency to despise Blacks
were not just a
social norm, but official church and government
policy.
Yet if you see the White South Africans in Uganda
today, they are
among the friendliest people you can meet.
They are so popular, they play Rugby and Cricket
with Ugandans, they
are always at Ugandan parties mixing and laughing
with Ugandans, and
even wearing Ugandan traditional dress. Many of
these White South
Africans date Ugandan men or Ugandan girls.
I have wondered to myself, "Are these the racists
that the world
portrayed them to be?". It is so hard to connect
apartheid South
Africa with the White South Africans living and
working in Uganda.
I told my friends in Addis Ababa that if you were to
conduct an
opinion poll over who they think are more racist,
Ethiopians or White
South Africans, 70 percent of people anywhere in the
world would
answer that they think Ethiopians are more racist or
at least more
socially discriminating.
When the apartheid era in South Africa came to an
end, the White
South Africans displayed the character which, I
think, explains why
the are beginning to spread all over Africa and
dominate it.
As I have mentioned, the White South Africans
quickly threw off their
racist policies and began to unite with the rest of
Africa. That flexibility of mind still surprises me. At last
week's United
Nations
racism conference, a large number of White South
Africans were part
of the crowds on the streets of Durban, South
Africa, to demonstrate
their opposition to racism.
Whether that gesture is hypocritical or not, at
least it demonstrates
a pragmatic attitude, considering that the White
South Africans were
raised to believe in racial separation.
So if Ethiopians say that their isolation and closed
country, their
culture, and upbringing are largely responsible for
their aloofness
from the rest of Africa, they should take a look at
the White South
Africans and see the importance of flexibility, of
recognizing the
need to come out and mix, and be seen to mix with
the rest of Africa.
As noted before, the White South Africans are,
today, some of the
most popular Africans in Black Africa. Who would
have thought that
this would ever happen, as recent as just 10 years
ago, considering
the reputation of White South Africa!
It would be a pity if as time goes on, many people
begin to think
that the White South Africans, with all their racist
background, are
bactually more social than the Ethiopians. Something
has to be done
about this reputation that Ethiopians have around
the world.
That impression of being unable to relate with other
Africans is one
that Ethiopians leave behind them everywhere they
go. They give
people the impression that they are uncomfortable
with and cannot
adjust to other people from other nationalities.
Of course I who has taken the time to understand
Ethiopia, know
better than most Ugandans. I know the realness, the
sincerity of
Ethiopians, the hospitality that they are capable
of. But most other
people think of Ethiopians that way, as racists, as
more racists than
even the White people.
This is something Ethiopians should at least be
aware of.
You don't need to persuade me to see how warm
Ethiopians are. I
already know it well. But it is important to bear in
mind the effect
the social upbringing of reserve and distance from
foreigners has had
on Ethiopians.
This reserved character is very easily misunderstood
as pride,
racism, and looking down on other people. I myself
first
misunderstood it in the Ethiopian women when I went
to Addis Ababa.
With time, I came to see how mistaken I had been.
But not all people from other countries have the
time or energy to
patiently understand that this reserved attitude is
not pride; it is
just the upbringing.
Ethiopia's true greatness
Despite this article's discussion of some of the
weaknesses in
Ethiopian society, it cannot go forward without
mentioning the single
greatest strength of Ethiopia. For all the things
that Ethiopians say
to prove their greatness --- being mentioned in the
Bible many times,
never been colonized, historic buildings in the
north of the country,
unique alphabet, and so on --- I have never heard a
single Ethiopian
talk about what I think is perhaps the greatest
thing about Ethiopia.
It is so strange, because it is the most outstanding
thing about
Ethiopia. The things Ethiopians say make their
country great are not
so great or if they are great, are not exclusive to
Ethiopia.
Many European countries like England, Spain, France,
Belgium, and
Austria have very fine castles. They have their fine
national
costumes. Many African countries have very rich and
colourful
languages.
I personally think the richly harmonized music of
the Zulu music in
South Africa, and the haunting, sad music of the
Fulani people in
Senegal and Mali (Mori Kante, Yussour N'Dor, Toure
Kunda, Selif
Keita) is the most beautiful in Africa.
So Ethiopia's heritage is as rich as that of many
other countries.
In my opinion, the greatest thing about Ethiopia is
its strong family
ties. In this area, it beats almost all countries in
the advanced
West and many even in Africa.
Let me explain. I wrote an article in one of the
Ugandan newspapers
last week comparing the mentality of Ethiopian girls
with that of
Ugandan girls. I was quite critical of our girls'
mentality.
In Uganda, there is a strange twisted side to our
girls' thinking
that I find annoying. It seems that girls in Uganda,
especially urban
Uganda, are attracted to men or boys who bring out
the worst in them.
The more "notorious" and "dangerous" a man
is, the
more the girls
find him attractive!
It sounds perverted, but it is true. In the social
pages of our
national newspapers, there is a constant stream of
articles that
portray "bad boys", men who cheat on their wives, or
who chase about
women, as some sort of heroes. These sorts of men as
very popular
with most girls, even girls who are well educated.
Many girls in Kampala, when they meet men who treat
them well, with
respect and courtesy, come away complaining that
these "nice guys"
are boring! I tried to understand this twisted way
of thinking in
Ugandan women, until I gave up. And I think the
Kenyan girls are like
that too. Maybe it comes from watching too many
American films
showing "bad guys" as heroes.
My most pleasant surprise about Ethiopian society is
that this sort
of nonsense that you find in Uganda is almost
absent.
The more affectionate, respectful, the more caring
and loving you are
to an Ethiopian girl, the more she will "fall for
you", the more she
finds you attractive. That is the way it should be.
I have seen this
across the whole Ethiopian society.
On that front, Ethiopia gets a gold medal and that
is why I say this
is Ethiopia's true greatness, that a society can
instill in its
children a healthy emotional constitution. Ethiopian
children are
close to their parents, and Ethiopian girls, I
notice, are close to
their fathers.
The society in general stresses close family ties,
where there is
someone always there to care about you, to visit you
or ring you up
and ask how you are.
In Uganda, even your best friend, someone you were
in school since
the age of seven, can go for three months without
giving you a phone
call to find out how you are. In Ethiopian society,
hardly a week can
go by without your friend in some way making contact
with you.
In Kampala, since the year began, most of the phone
calls I have
received at home, inviting me for a cup of coffee,
or asking why I
am "lost", or simply calling to say hello, come from
my Ethiopian
friends. These are people I met only this year.
Meanwhile, some of my very "best" friends are people
who last rang me
some eight months ago! That is why at the beginning
of this article,
I said I was so overwhelmed by the degree of
Ethiopian warmth and
sincerity while I was in Addis Ababa.
I don't know about the mental illness statistics in
Ethiopia, but
I
don't think you can find too many people who have
had mental
breakdowns and neurosis.
Many Ugandans have asked me why I am so in love with
Ethiopia and I
explain to them this realness, this human warmth and
companionship
that stretches across Ethiopian society.
Ethiopians, I tell them, are capable of being crazy,
irrational
people especially over matters to do with their
country. I am not
surprised that the country has had so much political
instability. You
see it in the people.
But at the same time, when you get close enough and
see the people,
you discover this realness, this true and heartfelt
warmth that many
of us in Uganda, and even those advanced western
countries simply
don't have.
I have never known why Ethiopians don't talk enough
about this
national trait, rather than tell us so much about
Emperor
Menelik's
famous battles. This close, caring, affectionate
side to Ethiopia is
far greater than all those battles and wars that
Ethiopians are so
fond of talking about.
I tried to understand why this is so. Could it be
because in Ethiopia
there are generally no boarding schools, unlike in
most countries in
Africa and Europe?
And so children grow up living at home with their
parents,
maintaining that close bond and companionship well
into their teenage
years, to university.
But whatever the explanation, this is the undisputed
greatest and
most beautiful thing about Ethiopia. I wish the
tourism brochures,
Selemta magazine, and other publications would
emphasize it more.
The Ethiopian Airlines in-flight magazine Selemta
talks in general,
rather vague terms about Ethiopian hospitality. I
think they manage
to describe only 40 percent of this hospitality.
They should ask me
to write an article for their next issue. I have
seen 80 percent of
Ethiopian hospitality. It is impressive.
Actually, it is wrong to describe it as hospitality.
It is more than
hospitality. It is a realness in people. The word
"hospitality"
sounds a little commercial and artificial.
So, to the many Ethiopians who have been asking me
why I have taken
such a sudden liking for their country, THAT IS THE
ANSWER! That,
more than anything else, is the reason I love
Ethiopia and why I am
going to love the country more as time goes on.
This is why, in the first place, I am engaged in
this debate over
Ethiopia's future and why I write these long
articles.
This realness, this sincerity of affection is what
attracts me most
about Ethiopia. I am not really interested in the
battles of Emperor
Menelik II, or the rock churches in Lalibela, or the
idea that
Ethiopia was never colonized.
It is great that this history was made. But that is
hundreds of years
ago. I am more impressed by these family values that
persist to this
day.
In a world where there is so much craziness and
mental weirdness, I
treasure the simplicity of the Ethiopians. The
Tanzanians have it too.
Ethiopians should be proud of this realness and most
of all, their
girls should thank God that they were raised in such
a way as to have
straight, emotionally healthy minds, since it is
they who pass on the
societies' values to the children. Just ask the
people who live
in
America, who see the twisted, perverted minds of
those children.
You will wonder why anyone would want to go to
America and raise his
or her children there.
It hurts me that people as nice and authentic as the
Ethiopians
should be facing such tough economic times, with
most so poor,
unhappy with life and not free, when lousy people
like us in Uganda
are enjoying an exciting and free life, full of
laughter and fun all
day long.
PART 2: Did colonialism help or harm Africa? A study
of Ethiopia
coming out soon.
Related Story
Abyssinian Chronicles by Timothy Kalyegira. Kalyegira is a Ugandan journalist founder and publisher of Africa Almanac.
Back to
NewsPage